New York Law (NYLE) Practice Exam 2026 - Free NYLE Practice Questions and Study Guide

In a negligence action in New York, the proper venue is generally determined by the residence of the parties involved and where the cause of action occurred. In this scenario, Nina has moved to a different county, which may impact the venue depending on where the negligence occurred.

County B, County C, or County D could be appropriate venues based on specific circumstances such as where the incident leading to the negligence claim happened. New York Law allows an action to be commenced in a county where any of the parties reside, which means that if the defendant lives in these counties or if the incident occurred there, they would be valid options for venue.

Additionally, if the negligence occurred in one of those counties or Nina currently resides in one of those counties after her move, it establishes the basis for venue. Thus, citing all three counties as potential venues recognizes the flexibility afforded by the law concerning where a plaintiff may commence a lawsuit.