New York Law (NYLE) Practice Exam 2026 - Free NYLE Practice Questions and Study Guide

The correct answer is based on the timeline set forth by New York law regarding the prosecution's obligation to disclose evidence to the defendant. Under New York Criminal Procedure Law, the prosecution is required to provide certain disclosures within specific timeframes following a defendant's arraignment. In this case, the law stipulates that disclosures must occur within 20 days after arraignment.

The assertion that the prosecution’s disclosure occurred more than 20 days after Oscar's arraignment directly indicates that the timing was not in compliance with the legal requirements. This highlights the importance of adhering to the statutory timelines to ensure that defendants are adequately informed of the evidence against them and can prepare an effective defense.

Options suggesting that disclosure may occur before a certificate of compliance is filed or suggesting that it can happen at any time before certain deadlines overlook the necessity of the initial mandated timetable post-arraignment for timely disclosure. These timelines exist to protect defendants’ rights and ensure fairness in the criminal justice process. Therefore, when the disclosure extends beyond the legally established 20-day period, it is deemed untimely.